Wednesday, January 31, 2007

T.O.M.S.

And I don’t mean that asshole that was here yesterday. “T.O.M.S.” is an acronym that one of my best friends, -Ray, and I created as shorthand for The Other MomS at our children’s respective preschools. I have three kids ages 16, 15 and 5 (first and second marriage offspring, see?). My big kids went to the same preschool that my little kid goes to, so I have history with the place. I have known the director for a million years, I have lived in this city most of my life, I am from here.

The entire time that my big kids went to this preschool, only one mom ever reached out to me to even say hello. We were never invited to a birthday party. I was a young, uncertain single parent, terrified that others would know that I was that feared scourge, A Welfare Mother. I felt undeserving of friendship from what I thought were “real” moms who weren’t poor and divorced. Later, when I returned to the very same preschool with my youngest, I was mature, I knew who I was, I was married, financially secure, and comfortable in my own skin. It never occurred to me that I still wouldn’t fit in.

For the first three years that my son attended this school, we were not invited to a single birthday party. Mothers didn’t much respond to me when I said good morning. No one suggested a play date. Last year, my husband, who does not have any tattoos, who is a public figure in our fair city, who is as preppie, IBM-conservative in appearance as they come, was the parent who picked up our child after school. He chatted with the moms. They LOVED him. One suggested a play date. This information was relayed to me, so the next morning I stopped her to accept the invitation and exchange phone numbers.

I will never forget the look on her face when she realized that the kid she had invited over belonged to that horrible freak with the tattoo and weird clothes. She stammered, and it was awkward. I figured she’d never call me, but she did. I went to her bland, beige house, we chatted, the children played. It went okay. The following day at preschool, she snubbed me when I said hello. This went on. Her husband snubbed me as well. At one point, while sitting outside after school, her child went to sit next to me and she said, “Oh, let’s not sit THERE, honey, let’s sit over HERE.” T.O.M.S. closed rank and talked pointedly about events I was not invited to.

I’m a woman who is known for being outspoken and not shy, but that year was nearly my undoing. I would have terrible anxiety about picking the child up at school. I cried. I almost didn’t go to the annual Mother’s Day luncheon because I was paralyzed by the fear that no one would sit with me. I went anyway, glommed on to a mom I didn’t know very well, suffered through it. Around that same time, another mom approached my husband about a play date. He agreed. I was pissed, because I’d already had that dance, thanks.

This play date, however, went well. I liked this other mom. She liked me, and then, well, something happened. THIS mom is the daughter of a famous person. Because she peed on me, sniffed my butt and deemed me okay, T.O.M.S., even Bland Beige, suddenly became My Best Friends. I was asked to join frivolous mommy groups (Moms and More; I said when they come up with Moms and LESS, let me know), women spoke to me, I got invited to play dates and birthday parties. Bland Beige acts like we’ve known each other all our lives and are like, sisters. But only in front of other people. She’s not going to phone me up to chat or anything.

What happened next? Well, there’s apparently a requirement that there be a Mom We All Hate. I’m not it anymore, so someone else is. I spend a lot of time pointing out that I believe the new Mom We Hate is abused by her husband and that I have great sympathy for her. I refuse to gossip about her. I refuse to be mean. I keep thinking that we are adults.

This phenomenon is what Ilyka calls “fighting over the crumbs.” It’s the sort of social structures that form when a group has no real power and has been diminished by their culture. There’s a rush to conformity so that a group of women can feel superior to someone, anyone; in my case the wacky artist with the tattoo and funky wardrobe, in the new victim’s case, the one who isn’t hip to fashion and is socially awkward and hard to talk to. I have wrestled with this; wondering, how will women ever make any progress if this is what we’re taking up our time with? Not to get all biblical, but gossiping is possibly the deadliest of sins; it costs us the opportunity to band together and make our communities better places. What can we do, then, to forge new ground and move forward? I speak from a position in which I wear the golden handcuffs of a popular mom’s approval. I’m the cheerleader’s friend; they all think I’m a little weird, but they’re willing to tolerate their friend’s taste in oddballs. To a certain degree, I am the exotic pet. My friend –Ray, in Portland, has experienced the same thing, so it’s not just my little town. So I wonder, and ask, is it everyone’s experience? Where are the grown up women who appreciate interesting people? Why aren’t we more open to each other and able to celebrate our differences? We’re talking about preschool here; not the U.N. I will keep on being me, and I will always work to resist the urge to gossip. Because being gossiped about hurts, and the power gained from doing it is illusory at best. I don’t want to be part of the T.O.M.S. club.

12 comments:

ChasingMoksha said...

The whole dynamics sound disgusting, like a high school pecking order or something. And so fake. I could not do it. If they would not talk to me before I would have too much resentment to talk to them now. I have a child very young and spent every bit of my money to put her in a school that I could not afford. I thought no one talked to me because they could see my poorness, but I found out years later it was because I was young and pretty. Now I have another child, seventeen years younger than the last and I do not talk to anyone at her school because I think they are all too young and trifling. I did not get patience with age.

gennimcmahon said...

I guess I fancy myself some sort of pioneer, hoping that if I model better behavior, I'll affect the future dynamic. Surely I delude myself; but then again, I would hate to be the reason my kid doesn't get invited to anything. It just means that it's not that relaxing to hang out; I have to be very careful and mindful of how I got there. You are right, chasingmoksha, it is terribly artificial, and what's gained from it?

Shinobi said...

I love your tattoo, it is beautiful.

My favorite thing on earth is seeing women who have peircings or tattoos and children, especially when these women also have successful business careers. I LOVE that it makes uptight people get all uptight. I imainge I would love it less if it were me though. (Once when I had purple hair this woman literally dragged her kid away from me like I was going to stop on her but I wouldn't have done that she was cute, and she liked the bright colors.)

I'm so sorry that there are people in the world that are this boring and small minded. And I'm doubly sorry you have to deal with them.

ilyka said...

You know I always love a good TOMS story. Especially--

We’re talking about preschool here; not the U.N.

--because it is very, very cute, so cute it thaws even my black heart, to imagine preschoolers sitting 'round the table (on booster seats, naturally) at the U.N.

ilyka said...

Ooh, one more thing, mom-related: Did you see this?

Helen said...

The grown-up women, who appreciate differences? I've got a load of them here by me. Just move to the south of England, you'll be just fine.

But you can sit by me, if you want. We can compare tattoos, and our conservative-looking men can woo the women. I'll bring margartias. You like salt?

Deborah said...

I love your tattoo. I didn't fit in at preschool either, but I was not exactly snubbed. And I wasn't fully sleeved until my son was seven. Still, I'm so fucking used to not fitting in that it's okay in its way.

gennimcmahon said...

I'm always surprised by the need for conformity. If all my friends looked like me, I'd be bored witless. I like people for the themselves, not their outward appearance. I guess that makes me unusual. One of the blandest, least threatening seeming moms at the school is a swinger. Another is a white supremacist. You really never know.

Ilyka, I DID see that, and thought WOW, they hadn't ought to come to my house. A glass of wine? A glass of wine? Truly, the Puritans never really die.

gennimcmahon said...

Helen, darling, on the rocks and yes, with salt. I love you.

And, should I ever get to the UK (drugs will ease my fear of flying, yes?), you are the one person I know I'm comin' to see.

Lesley said...

Reason #5,493 why I will probably never move more than 10 miles outside a large urban center. I grew up in the suburbs, and I hated that whole dynamic. I'm very lucky to be able to afford to live where I do (Manhattan). At least here, you have a lot of different groups, so you can find the one you fit in with. Geeky, sci-fi loving accountants? No problem. Tattooed artists? No problem. Tattooed accountants? No problem.

This is not to say that there are no bad social dynamics here, because there are. The groups hardly co-mingle. And Manhattan is weirdly segregated. It's one of the things about it that really pisses me off. There's Manhattan below 96th Street and Manhattan above 96th Street. Ride the subway, and you will see how the color balance changes once you cross 96th Street. Most non-Hispanic whites and Asians get off before 96th, and most blacks and Hispanics get off after. It's not 100%, but it's very noticeable.

Sage said...

I've had this same issue with other moms. My kids are 12, 10, and 2, so I'm not quite at the stage of seeing if the scenario plays itself out the same the second time around. But you know, I've got five tattoos, and it never even occurred to me that my body decorations could be the reason why moms avoid me!! I always figured it's because I'm not witty or chatty or wealthy enough. And when I was single, I figured it was because the married women didn't know what to do with a single person coming over (or something like that). But in our neighbourhood, just like you, my guy is a hit, and I'm still an outcast. Weird. On the plus side, they give me lots of material to write about.

It never ceases to amaze me how few people really leave that high school mentality.

gennimcmahon said...

Sage, I'm reminded of a dear friend I had in high school. We went to a party one night, where the guys were smoking pot. My friend stepped right up for some of that, and some of the "popular" girls walked by, holding their wine coolers, and gave my friend the most withering of looks. Like, those wine coolers made them so much more ladylike than a girl that would smoke pot. Only whores smoke pot; nice girls drink wine coolers.

That's exactly how it is with my tattoo; sure, it's okay to get a unicorn on your left breast or a heart on your ankle, but a full sleeve? Junkie hooker fer shur.

The arbitrary standards just never end.